The Ultimate Debate: Are Manual Drivers Really Cooler?

Let’s be honest: the manual vs. automatic transmission debate is one of those age-old arguments that stir up passion, memes, and maybe even a little friendly rivalry. You know, the kind—like whether pineapple belongs on pizza or if a hot dog counts as a sandwich. But when it comes to actually driving, the question remains: Are manual drivers cooler? Prepare yourself for an engaging discussion that will blend humor, facts, and affection for both sides of the stick shift.

The Manual Mystique: Why Do People Think It’s Cool?

Manual drivers possess an unmistakable charm. Maybe it’s how they glide through gears, with their left foot tapping the clutch like they’re playing a piano. Or maybe it’s the pure satisfaction of nailing a perfect heel-toe downshift. Manual driving is a form of art, and those who master it proudly display their skill.

And let’s not forget the cultural side of things. Movies and TV have turned manual driving into icons. Think Steve McQueen in Bullitt, ripping through the streets of San Francisco in a manual Mustang. Or Dominic Toretto in Fast & Furious, dropping the famous line, “It’s not just about cars, it’s about family” (while clearly shifting gears with passion). Manual driving is often seen as the choice of rebels, racers, and free spirits. It’s no surprise people link it with coolness.

Photo: Warner Bros/Kobal

The Automatic Appeal: Convenience Is King  

On the other hand, automatic drivers are currently experiencing the best life possible. So, why fix what isn’t broken? They are also enjoying the freedom from constant clutch-and-shift maneuvers in traffic. Today's automatic transmissions are not only more convenient and efficient, but they have also advanced significantly.  Modern automatics and dual-clutch transmissions can shift faster than humans, so they’re the go-to choice for performance cars and daily drivers.

Now… let’s talk about accessibility. Not everyone wants to (or can) drive a manual, so that’s okay! Automatics let everyone in on the joy of driving, and inclusivity is never uncool. Add to that the surge of electric vehicles (which don’t even have traditional transmissions), and we are headed for an automatic future.

The Skill Factor: Does Driving Manual Make You a Better Driver?

One common argument made by manual drivers is that driving a stick shift improves your driving skills. And sure, there’s some truth in that. Driving a manual car requires more coordination, focus, and understanding of how your car works. You’re more one with the vehicle, able to feel every shift and rev in a way an automatic simply can’t.

But does it make you a better driver? Not necessarily. No matter the pedal configuration, a good driver understands and adheres to the road rules. So, although manual drivers might have been able to show off a handful of additional skills, it doesn’t inherently (pun intended) mean their skills are any superior.

The Coolness Quotient: It’s All About Perspective  

At the end of the day, whether manual or automatic is “cool” really comes down to personal preference. If you’re into the hands-on feel of shifting gears, yeah, you’re probably going to think driving a manual is pretty awesome. But if you’re an automatic driver who loves convenience and all the modern tech, that’s cool, too.

What really matters is the joy of driving. Whether you're engaging with the gears or allowing the car to operate autonomously, the exhilaration of driving on the open road unites us. Instead of pitting manual and automatic drivers against each other, let's celebrate various driving experiences. After all, isn’t that what makes car culture so great?

Who Wins the Coolness Crown?

Are manual drivers really cooler? Well, it depends. If coolness means skill, tradition, and a bit of nostalgia, then manual drivers might win. But if coolness is about innovation, practicality, and the future of driving, automatics are just as cool.

Ultimately, the most stylish drivers sincerely appreciate their vehicles, whether traditional stick-shift or contemporary automatic. Let’s stop arguing and enjoy both. The road has room for everyone.

Pedal Commander, whether manual or automatic, is your go-to tool for enhancing your driving experience. With its advanced throttle response system, Pedal Commander reduces lag, giving you immediate power when needed.



Whether pulling off a precise downshift in a manual or making your automatic feel more engaging, Pedal Commander allows you to fine-tune your throttle sensitivity for a custom driving experience.

Pedal Commander offers four adjustable modes: Eco, City, Sport, and Sport+. These modes enable you to transition seamlessly from fuel-saving cruising to high-performance acceleration. Easy plug-and-play installation means no complex wiring—plug in and play. So get yours now. 

After all, what’s cooler than having total control over your acceleration?